Friday, 22 February 2013
Assessing Recruitment Candidates
Having participated on ‘both sides’ of an independent assessment process (as a recruitment candidate as well as a manager assessing candidates) I fully recommend it as a means of identifying the most appropriate candidate for the role.
I say this there are a number of benefits of using an independent process over the traditional interview for both the employer as well as the candidate.
Firstly, the process provides a wider range of information about a candidate than just an interview and therefore as an employer you are more likely to make the right decision. Secondly, the process is transparent and independent which is a comfort to both the organisation and candidates. It avoids any ‘halos or horns’ effect of managers assessing internal candidates ensuring that all candidates (both internal and external) are assessed on equal and fair terms. Lastly, (and if done properly!)the feedback to candidates following the assessment can be invaluable in helping them develop in their new role (if they are recruited) or learn new skills that will help them to land their next job. Personally I found the last point invaluable following the first assessment centre I attended many years ago.
So what are the keys to making an assessment process successful? The following are my observations and recommendations.
1. To ensure independence, use an external organisation who have fully trained and competent assessors and can tailor their assessment tools for your organisation.
2. Be clear about the success criteria for the role. For example, what level of leadership skill is needed, does the role require strategic thinking and/or analytical skills? What type of communication skills and behaviours are important too?
3. Use a range of assessment tools to identify the key skills and behaviours you wish to measure. These might include a personality profile, attainment tests as well as a number of tools designed around the business and job role (e.g. business case scenarios, role plays, presentations etc.).
4. Use a simple scoring system. I recommend that at least three pieces of evidence are used to provide an assessment of each criteria.
5. Once scored the candidates can be ranked in terms of closest fit for the role as well as their potential to fulfil other roles. In my experience assessing potential is just as important as assessing job fit because it provides valuable information about candidates who can fulfil other roles in the business or alternatively be a successor to the person recruited.
6. Once the decision is made and communicated on who to appoint I recommend each candidate receives 1:1 feedback from the assessor(s) on how they performed at the assessment centre. It is important to remember that the feedback is not about the candidate’s ability to fulfil their current role but for the role advertised. My view is that the feedback should focus on the candidate’s strengths and development needs and what they can do to get themselves in a position to be successful. In this way the feedback is more likely to be motivating for the candidate.
As I mentioned at the start, having participated on ‘both sides’ of an independent assessment centre I fully recommend it as a means of fairly and equitably identifying the most appropriate candidate(s) for the role and hopefully my experiences will provide you with a useful start to running an assessment process for your organisation.
Wednesday, 6 February 2013
Leading Change
I have witnessed many changes fail, from poorly implemented CRM systems that have compromised the organisation’s ability to service their customers effectively to inadequately executed acquisitions where the full business benefits were never realised. So why do so many large scale changes fail to live up to management’s expectations?
I believe there are a number of pre-requisites for successful change. Some of these have been well documented over the years and a few are from my own observations and experience. Successful change happens when:
1. There is a compelling need (i.e. ‘we have to do this because….’) for the change and a clear vision for it. If change is simply a ‘good idea’ or a ‘nice thing to do’ it is likely to fail.
2. Leaders in the business demonstrate their commitment to change by regularly ‘walking the table’. So if the change involves restructuring and cost cutting, it’s probably best if senior managers don’t travel first class!
3. Employees understand what the changes mean for them personally and what they will be expected to do differently.
4. Managers and their staff are involved in and can help shape the changes in the areas that they are responsible for. Dictating change is rarely a recipe for success!
5. People involved in the change are regularly communicated to, they are listened to and their concerns are managed and dealt with promptly and effectively.
6. Individuals have the skills, capability and confidence to manage the reaction to change both in themselves and their teams.
7. Everyone is encouraged to behave in line with the changes and consequential actions taken if they don’t.
8. People are given the time and space to implement change as well as doing their day job. Staff need to be given time away from their day job to make changes happen.
As I mentioned previously, I have seen many changes fail, mainly due to management not taking cognisance of one or more of the points above, and as a consequence not getting the engagement and commitment of their people to change too.
Thursday, 31 January 2013
What Makes a Great Leader?
Characteristics of Leaders
There are lots of articles about that have been written on what makes a great leader and what the characteristics of successful leaders are. I am sure you know someone who was great was an intelligent and skilled individual who was great at their job and who was promoted into a leadership position and then sadly failed. You may also know someone who wasn’t the best at their job but had certain traits and abilities that enabled them to succeed when promoted into a leadership role.
Some say identifying individuals who have the right leadership abilities is not a science! Personally I have a different view.
So what characteristics do successful leaders have?
• Integrity – They have integrity, they do what they say they will and are trusting of others too.
• Vision – They know where they want their organisation to go and are able to communicate it and it explain to others
• Goals – They break their vision into clear SMART goals
• Team Working – They encourage working together as a team and empower their team to understand issues, create solutions and act on them!
• Communication – They are constantly in touch with key individuals in the organisation and engage regularly with others on a face to face basis as well as via email and other means
• Inspiration – They are someone that other employees look up to for direction
• Ambition – They have ambition, both in terms of wanting to be a leader but also they constantly strive for improvement and success
I have seen many leaders’ loose trust and credibility quickly by ignoring these fundamental ‘leadership rules’.
In summary as a leader you need to be there for your staff, demonstrating trust and communicating with them whatever their role in the organisation.
Friday, 4 January 2013
Are you a new boss?
Have you been recently promoted or have you taken on a new role in a different company? If you have beware as it is very easy to come across as though the promotion or new role has gone to your head!
I have had bitter experience of this, just because I am in a more senior position than my colleagues I must know more than them! Don’t fall into the trap that I did and follow these simple steps to make sure you manage your credibility and authority:
1. Don’t send an email to all employees saying ‘I’m the boss now!’. You need to communicate your new role and to make everyone aware, use ‘low key’ methods. Such as a simple paragraph in the next company newsletter, or an introduction at a team meeting.
2. Make a few small decisions quickly, e.g. set up a new agenda for team meetings but do not try and re organise the whole department in the first week.
3. Talk about your vision. But also ask your team, ‘what can I do to make you more successful?’
4. If another employee is disappointed as they went for the same role as you but was unsuccessful then approach with caution. You need to let the person adjust to the situation that they were unsuccessful and then work with them to let them know that you want them to succeed and will coach and support them.
Remember these summary principles and you won’t go far too wrong:
DO-
Take actions that demonstrates your credibility
Support people going forward
Ask for feedback
DON’T-
Start re-organising the business right away
Forget to connect with your new peers and new boss
Maintain too close a relationship with peers
Build on the above steps you gain the confidence and respect from colleagues and peers and you will then have the foundations to be a great boss!
Thursday, 20 December 2012
Are you Stressed?
Are you feeling stressed?
At times it seems like we all have just too much to do with too little time to do it in. I often feel stressed at key points in the year, christmas, holiday time, and at times when there are too many people off work and workload is passed onto me when I have enough of my own to do!
I know it is easier said than done but I sometimes try to take a step back and try to de-stress myself by doing the following:
1. Think about the progress you have made – It can sometimes be very easy to feel as though you are getting nowhere. Take a moment to reflect on what you have achieved so far before looking at the challenges ahead.
2. Take time out to do something you find interesting but remember interesting is not necessarily the same thing as fun, pleasant or relaxing. Remember if it interests you and gives you replenished energy then do it!
3. Your to do list – Your to do list can sometimes seem endless and it is simply a list of tasks. Have you ever thought about adding a where and when to your list? Research has shown that that if you decide when and where you will complete a task it can double or triple your chance of doing it. For example, call Dawn in HR, could be call Dawn in HR on Tuesday after a lunch out with the boss. It is called seizing the critical moment.
4. Use a routine. Try and reduce stress by reducing the number of decisions you make and use routines. For example, respond to emails at a certain time in the day, have a break at 10.30 every day. In fact in a recent interview President Obama, (who I am sure knows a great deal about stress ), mentioned using this strategy himself: ‘You need to remove from your life day to day problems that absorb most people for meaningful parts of their day.. You’ll see I wear only grey or blue suits. I’m trying to cut down decisions. I don’t want to make decisions about what I’m eating or wearing because I have too many other decisions to make. You need to focus your decision making energy. You need to get into a routine, you can’t be going through the day distracted by trivia’ quote from ( President Obama – Vanity Fair)
5. Look at the big picture – it is sometimes useful to link your smaller actions to the big picture to give you a sense of achievement.
6. Take a break – finally we are all human and yes it is OK to take a break.
Follow these simple steps to a stress less 2013!
Monday, 17 December 2012
Putting your People First
I recently read an article calling business leaders to pay more attention to ‘the 3P’s’.
This interested me, was this phrase simply another management acronym or was there some substance behind what I read?
The three P’s stand for:
PEOPLE before
PRODUCT (or service) before
PROFIT (or performance).
The sequence and the word before each P is extremely significant. The phrasing states that, if you ensure your people are capable, creative and engaged, they will in turn produce great products (and/or services), which will lead to a successful, high performing business which is profitable and successful..
However how many businesses really think in this way?
I have worked for many businesses who engaged far too much ‘top down’ management. They strive for profit and performance without paying attention to engaging their people in doing the right things.
I have witnessed businesses pay huge salaries and big bonuses to focus staff on sales and profit targets and while bonuses can act as an ‘extrinsic motivator’, in reality they only provide a short term impact at best. They do not truly engage staff and are soon forgotten.
So what does putting your People before Product and Profit mean?
In my view if a business is going to truly put their people first they have to do a number of things. For example, they need to:
- Understand the innate skills and capabilities of the people they have.
- Be clear about what is expected from everyone.
- Support their managers and staff to develop skills that will make them more effective in their jobs.
- Give their staff as much autonomy as possible trust them to do their job and give them the freedom to make their own decisions.
- Involve their staff in decisions that affect them more.
- Listen and pay attention to what their staff say, their concerns, and ideas for improvement, and ACT on them.
Finally I believe that senior execs need to recognise and understand that the culture of the business is dictated by their behaviour. They must therefore work hard to develop the necessary behaviours to enable them to act as excellent role models, and demonstrate on a day to day basis that they put their people first.
If a business truly desires to improve its performance, it must start with its people, their skills, capabilities, motivation and level of engagement.
Friday, 14 December 2012
The Importance of Talent Management
After working with many different businesses I have concluded that one of the biggest risks facing many organisations is having the right talent to enable them to compete in the future.
I see many businesses who have a significant number of key executives will likely retire in the next 5-10 years. While this may not have been an issue 10 or 15 years ago, pressure has been such that businesses have had to reorganise and resize themselves to a point where the talent pool that would have been ready to step up into key roles are either not ready or not there.
I also think this will be compounded in the longer term as fewer people stay with one organisation. For example, a recent study estimated that current school leavers will have between 10-14 jobs by their 40th birthday!
To address this issue, I believe that more companies need to integrate their talent and succession planning with their strategic business plans and view talent management as a long-term, continuous process. To achieve this I believe that businesses should:
• Think strategically. Talent management requires a strategic perspective. What are the things that might impact your organisation in the future? Will it grow and acquire other businesses, or is the market shrinking and therefore a different leadership approach may be needed? What ‘type’ of managers and business leaders will be needed in the future?
• Understand the businesses key roles. Which functions and roles in the organisation drive the majority of the business’s value? Businesses need to think broadly, and not just about traditional leadership roles. Specialist technical roles such as product development may be as equally important. Once this is complete it is a straightforward task to examine the age profiles of those currently in the key roles. How many of these could retire in the next 5-10 years? How many of these roles have ‘ready now’ successors?
• Identify the requirements of the key roles. Effective talent management requires clarity on technical and behavioural requirements for the roles as well as specific experience, such as international or specific market experience. All key roles should have the necessary components and characteristics for superior performance clearly defined. These requirements can then be used as a basis to assess people, either internally via a promotion or externally via recruitment.
• Agree a succession strategy. Once the organisation knows who is likely to retire, and who the potential talent is, objective decisions can be made about how the key roles will be filled in the future. This will enable the business to actively recruit and bring in new blood to fill roles that cannot be filled from within.
• Define career paths for internal promotions. Once a succession strategy is clear, establishing career paths and the ability to describe the requirements for pursuing the path becomes easier. Creating effective career paths requires two components, knowing the requirements for the next level and creating clear plan of how to gain the necessary skills, behaviours and experience.
• Link talent management and performance management together. Talent management and succession planning should become a part of the organisation’s performance management and career development processes. Regular performance discussions are important to collect evidence of how potential successors have progressed.
• Provide on-going development. Managers need to support the ongoing development of their talent to ensure that make the necessary progress.
• Monitor readiness and prepare a succession plan. Senior managers should meet at least annually to initially agree who the potential successors are for the key roles and to subsequently monitor their progress. Who is ready now to move to their next role? Is their evidence to suggest that any of the successors will not ‘make the grade’? If not what needs to be done?
What I have described may at first to appear a cumbersome process, but none of the above steps need to be made overly complex. If your business does not focus on talent management and succession planning then the availability of talent for your key roles will be left to the fickle finger of fate. Surely the future success of your business is too important for that?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)